At 6:00 a.m. tomorrow, Friday, November 6, the American Maverick is scheduled to tie up at the Mallory Square Pier. It stays 47 hours and leaves at 5:00 a.m. on Sunday. Through both of the evenings in between, the ship will do something no other cruise ship in Key West does. About 45 minutes before the sun goes down, it will pull away from the pier, and about 45 minutes after, it will come back.
That small ship, its two sister vessels and that nightly 90-minute gap are the whole cruise story at Mallory Square this winter. They are also at the center of a decision now in front of the Key West City Commission. A proposed agreement would make American Cruise Lines the main funder of the Mallory wharf repair and give it control of the pier calendar for at least ten years.
The timetable across the harbor
American Cruise Lines filed a "Selected Dockings Schedule" with the city, dated October 14, 2026. It shows three ships rotating through Mallory: the American Maverick, the American Pioneer and the American Ranger. Every call on it is marked confirmed. Here is November:
| Ship | Arrives 6:00 a.m. | Departs | Hours in port |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Maverick | Fri., Nov. 6 | Sun., Nov. 8, 5:00 a.m. | 47 |
| American Maverick | Fri., Nov. 13 | Sun., Nov. 15, 5:00 a.m. | 47 |
| American Pioneer | Mon., Nov. 16 | Wed., Nov. 18, 5:00 a.m. | 47 |
| American Maverick | Fri., Nov. 20 | Sun., Nov. 22, 5:00 a.m. | 47 |
| American Pioneer | Mon., Nov. 23 | Tue., Nov. 24, 4:00 p.m. | 34 |
| American Maverick | Fri., Nov. 27 | Sun., Nov. 29, 5:00 a.m. | 47 |
| American Pioneer | Mon., Nov. 30 | Wed., Dec. 2, 4:00 a.m. | 46 |
The pace picks up in December. The American Ranger joins on December 2, and from then until New Year's Day 2027 the three ships hand the pier off to one another almost without a break. On several mornings one ship leaves before dawn and the next arrives at 6:00 a.m. The Ranger's call that starts December 30 runs until 5:00 a.m. on January 1.
So in practice, a ship is at Mallory most nights this season. It is the same kind of small ship every time, and it works on a calendar anyone can read.
Why only this kind of ship ties up at Mallory
The size of the ships comes from a rule the city adopted in 2022. In March of that year, the commission passed Resolution 22-073. It defined a cruise ship as any vessel able to carry 500 or more people, counting passengers and crew, and directed those ships away from city-owned property and toward Pier B. According to city staff, the practical result is that only vessels under 500 people dock at the Mallory T-Pier. Keys Weekly reported at the time that the compromise sent ships of any size to Pier B, one at a time.
The city chose that route because its first approach was blocked. According to the same Keys Weekly report, state preemption nullified the 2020 ballot measures that proposed a daily passenger cap and a limit on ship size. For ports that receive or are eligible for state funding under that chapter, Section 311.25 of the Florida Statutes still bars ballot measures from restricting vessel type, size, number or passenger counts. A second limit on Mallory is much older. An agreement with Ocean Key Resort and Spa that dates to 1989, renewed by the city in September 2023, caps the length of any vessel at the T-Pier. City staff say that cap alone would keep out most ships carrying more than 500 passengers plus crew, even if Resolution 22-073 were ever overturned.
A large ship on the same calendar shows the difference in scale. One published timetable lists the Celebrity Apex in Key West on Sunday, November 29, from 10:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., with a listed capacity of 2,910 passengers. The American Maverick leaves Mallory at 5:00 a.m. that same morning.
Port traffic overall remains well below where it was before the pandemic. Key West Chamber of Commerce figures drawn from city Port Operations data show 212 cruise calls and 570,015 passenger arrivals from January through November 2025. The same months of 2019 had 370 calls and 863,279 passengers.
The 90 minutes the pier goes empty
"Their vessels leave the pier 45 minutes prior to sunset and return 45 minutes after, accommodating the nightly Sunset Celebration while complying with the City's submerged lands lease."
That line comes from the city manager's memo on the proposed agreement.
The ritual dates back at least to the first season. In 2024, Keys Weekly described an American Cruise Lines ship leaving the dock for about an hour each evening so it would not block the sunset view. The memo also gives the reason the ships stay so long. The line runs multi-night cruises out of St. Petersburg with Key West as a featured stop, and its port visits average 47 hours.
For anyone watching the Old Town waterfront from the water side, this means a ship sits at Mallory through most of the day and night but moves away for the evening. Each night it sails off before sunset and comes back after dark, on a schedule set by the time of sunset.
Five million dollars toward an aging wharf
The rest of the agreement makes sense once you see the condition of the pier. In its capital projects plan for fiscal 2025/26, the city describes the Mallory Square wharf as in need of repair or replacement. An inspection by TetraTech found spalling on the undersides of the precast deck panels and the pier caps. The project estimate is $7,645,051, with $7.5 million allocated in FY2025/26. The plan funds that with $4,896,536 from the city's Fund 101 and a $2,603,464 Tourist Development Council grant, and it targets completion on October 1, 2027. Keys Weekly reported in October 2025 that the Monroe County TDC had set aside more than $2.6 million for the Mallory Square seawall. A separate first phase of plaza work, estimated at $11,946,697, has the same October 2027 target, and the plan calls for phasing construction so the plaza stays open for the sunset celebrations.
The proposed Mallory T-Pier Use Agreement brings American Cruise Lines into that budget. As city documents describe it, the terms are:
- Term: ten years, with two five-year renewal options. The current agreement is labeled "3+3."
- Contribution: $5 million toward the Mallory Wharf and Pier project, paid in two $2.5 million installments. The first comes when the city signs a construction contract and the second when construction is finished.
- Control: the cruise line would manage reservations for the whole T-Pier. The city would approve every third-party booking and split third-party docking revenue 50/50. Staff note the city has received no third-party revenue at the pier in the past two years.
- Fees: $14.21 per passenger and $4.10 per linear foot per calendar day, adjusted each year by CPI-U with a 3% cap.
Measured against the wharf estimate, the $5 million would cover about two-thirds of the repair. The city manager's office recommends approval. The first agreement was awarded on September 12, 2024, for three years with an option for three more. The new version would extend the arrangement into the late 2030s, and further if both renewals are used.
The other pier that went quiet
Mallory matters more now because the city's other cruise berth is gone. Above the Fold reported that the U.S. Navy ended the city's lease on the Outer Mole Pier at Naval Air Station Key West, effective August 3, 2026. That lease covered about 800 linear feet of pier. In an April commission discussion, City Manager Brian Barroso said that without cruise revenue tied to the pier, the city could no longer afford the insurance and lease obligations. In May, the Navy issued a Request for Interest seeking ideas for the berth and described it as market research, not a formal solicitation. On July 1, Keys Weekly reported, commissioners voted 5ā2 to ask Navy leaders to respect the city's voter-approved cruise preferences, while acknowledging that the pier is under federal control.
That leaves the Mallory T-Pier as the one cruise dock the city controls directly, and American Cruise Lines is the only operator on its schedule.
December 10 on the calendar
The commission meets today, Thursday, November 5, at 9:00 a.m. at City Hall. On its final agenda, file 26-6052 is listed as a "Request for Postponement to December 10, 2026" on the American Cruise Lines use agreement. The city accepts public comment on the meeting through its eComment page, and the meeting record on Legistar will post the outcome once the minutes are final. If the commission grants the postponement, the vote would come on December 10. The American Ranger is due at Mallory at 6:00 a.m. the day before and stays through 5:00 a.m. on December 11.
The pier schedule doesn't depend on the vote, at least through New Year's Day. All of those calls are already confirmed, and on each of those evenings the ship is due to leave Mallory before sunset and return after dark.
At Bob Cardenas and Sunset Key Residences, we keep an eye on that harbor and on what Key West decides about it, from the pier calendar to the December vote. If you want to talk about a Sunset Key home that faces this water, we would be glad to show you around. Explore Properties on Sunset Key.